TRENTON -- The debate over debates is not over.
Just 12 hours after scoring a relatively narrow victory in the Republican Senate primary last night, Republican nominee Dick Zimmer immediately turned his attention to incumbent Senator and Democratic nominee Frank Lautenberg by asking him to participate in a series of debates, starting next Friday.
It was déjà vu all over again, with Zimmer taking a page out of Democratic challenger Rob Andrews's playbook. But Zimmer said that the idea came not from the Andrews camp, but from Lautenberg's 1982 campaign against Republican Millicent Fenwick, when he demanded 21 debates - one in each county in the state - something Andrews also said on the campaign trail.
"Twenty-six years ago, Frank Lautenberg said that candidates have, and I quote, ‘an obligation to let citizens make their own decisions through more debates.' I agree with that philosophy."
It would start with one hosted by the New Jersey Association of Counties, which has invited Zimmer and Lautenberg.
"I ask Sen. Lautenberg to join me immediately in accepting the debate as part of a framework that was agreed to two years ago between incumbent Sen. Bob Menendez and his challenger, Tom Kean, (Jr.)," said Zimmer.
Zimmer, 64, pledged that he would not bring up Frank Lautenberg's age of 84, as Andrews said. He added that the negative tenor of the Democratic race was a result of the two candidates having few philosophical differences, whereas he and Lautenberg have much to disagree on. Take, for instance, his opposition to earmarks that he's based his short campaign on so far.
"It will be a spirited debate between Sen. Lautenberg and myself, the un-Lautenberg. We have diametrically different philosophies," said Zimmer. "Sen. Lautenberg thinks it's ok to send $250 million to Alaska for a bridge to nowhere, and accept and exchange a few hundred thousand dollars for blueberry research in the state of New Jersey."
Instead, Zimmer said that the campaign will focus on what Lautenberg said mattered all along: effectiveness, and said that the only bill Lautenberg wrote that became law was the renaming of the West Milford post office.
"I have no problem with Frank Lautenberg's character. I think he does the right thing by his own likes and has accomplished some good things in his years in the senate, but has not been an effective advocate for the people of New Jersey."
The Republican primary which Zimmer entered into late did take a negative turn, with rival Joe Pennacchio blasting Zimmer for taking a farmland assessment tax break and Zimmer pushing back with radio ads excerpting Pennacchio's controversial 1991 policy paper called A Nationalist Agenda.
But Zimmer said Pennacchio and Murray Sabrin both called him with gracious concessions last night and offered to help him in his general election campaign. And he said that he wasn't afraid of the tax break he gets on his Hunterdon County farm would be an effective attack against him by Lautenberg.
"According to New Jersey farm bureau, it's the most successful agricultural protection program there is in New Jersey," he said.
Zimmer also categorically denied that he ever used controversial ‘angry black man' robocalls during his 2000 congressional campaign against Rush Holt, a charge outlined in the book How to Rig an Election by former political operative Alan Raymond.
"That is an untrue statement made by a convicted felon. It didn't happen," he said.
Zimmer wouldn't say what his fundraising goals are, but thinks that he will have enough money to get his message out.
"We expect to be outspent, but we expect to win," he said.
Lautenberg spokeswoman Julie Roginsky also sounded a campaign theme that's been familiar over the last couple months: she tied Zimmer to President Bush.
"Dick Zimmer is a long-time Washington Republican who eagerly signed on to Gingrich's failed Contract for America. Now he marches in lockstep with George Bush by opposing a timeline for withdrawal from Iraq and therefore supports giving this Administration a blank check to continue this misguided war indefinitely. New Jersey and the nation have voted time and again for a change from the failed Bush policies that Dick Zimmer so wholeheartedly endorses," she said in a statement.
Roginsky said that Lautenberg would participate in debates with Zimmer, but did not offer any commitments.
We believe that debates are an integral part of any campaign and we look forward to contrasting Senator Lautenberg's progressive record of delivering for the state of New Jersey and with Dick Zimmer's support of Bush Administration policies, but we will not be debating debates with our opponent."
Through the window of Johnny Rockets in Denver, Gov. Jon Corzine can be seen getting down to “Staying Alive” on Wednesday night. >
One hesitates to quote Shakespeare to the Editors of The Record. The thought of all that dust rising from their library shelves is enough to make me ... >
A Post columnist contends that New Jersey offers a cautionary tale to New York. He's right. >
Selecting the next NJN anchor will certainly be a different process than what happens at the major networks, local affiliates and other public ... >
Tibet – the broad, high plateau between India and China – is bigger than Western Europe and the source of the great rivers of Asia: the Indus, ... >
For the past few weeks, I've watched with fascination as politician after politician have appeared on a beach or a boardwalk and declared their ... >
Check back tomorrow morning to view my sketchpad for day three of the Democratic National Convention, and go to my national blog to follow >
Some time ago, I analyzed the Catholic vote and noted in passing how some members of the Church hierarchy, in places such as St. Louis and Colorado ... >
Joey Novick from Politics Unusual spent the entire week live blogging from the Convention. Here are his daily posts, exclusive to PolitickerNJ.com. >
During a gubernatorial debate in 2005, then-U.S. Sen. Jon Corzine was asked if he supported lowering the drinking age to 18.
"I think it is ... >
The best candidate won yesterday's primary
Dick Zimmer will give Lautenberg the toughest opposition that he has ever had. After watching Frank last night, the contrast will obvious - Zimmer is the man for the job.
Lautenberg Should Grant Zimmer 2 Debates
...in the last days of the campaign. Just to show that he's functioning and has a general command of the issues. That's fair enough.
The differences on policy between these two is so blatant and deeply substantial that the cases can be made in writing and in campaign materials/commercials.
As for,
"Zimmer also categorically denied that he ever used controversial ‘angry black man' robocalls during his 2000 congressional campaign against Rush Holt, a charge outlined in the book How to Rig an Election by former political operative Alan Raymond.
"That is an untrue statement made by a convicted felon. It didn't happen," he said."
I've heard Alan Raymond speak, and I've read through his book. Raymond was indeed a Republican hack/crook; but there is no reason to believe that he just made up these stories about Zimmer knowing that Zimmer would someday be running for Senate.
Zimmer should have just told the truth and apologized for past low blows. By lying and covering up his past campaign's history he only compounds his own lack of credibility.
No doubt, the "age" issue will, once again, be rearing it's ugly head from Zimmer surrogates/supporters.
Ageism is bigotry. Period.
A large majority of New Jerseyans will be voting to retain Senator Lautenberg in November because of the way he will vote on the actual issues; not because he's the slickest/quickest silver tongued con man in the state.
Meanwhile, to the extent that Zimmer succombs to the temptation to follow Rob Andrews' "lead" (i.e. a de facto personal attack on Lautenberg's competency based on his age); he will suffer the same fate. A crushing defeat.
If Zimmer runs a respectful and honorable campaign on the actual issues, he'll still lose....but by less.
The people of NJ don't want the thoroughly discredited Bush/Republican policies to do any more damage than they already have.
From Frederick Douglass
Gee, no one's ever done that before
This is not a page out of Lautenberg's playbook. Every challenger does it, and every incumbent ducks.
And the reason every incumbent does it is that the media writes about the nonissue, giving them free press and the "moral" high ground.
Congratulations.
No-Show Address
Launtenberg will be in New York until Election day.
No chance that he comes back to New Jersey for any debates.
I anticipate these
debates as much as a root canal. Frank says that he is Frank. Dick says that he isn't Frank. Bestill my racing heart. Thank you Tom Wilson!
Speaking of age...
Zimmer is 63, not 64. Not that age should play a factor!