May 15, 2008 - 1:38pm
Senators don't usually lose primaries
By Wally Edge
Category: US SenateTags: Harrison Williams, Frank Guarini, Walter Edge, Ronald Reagan, Robert Morris, Hamilton Kean, Jeff Bell, Joseph McCarthy
In New Jersey, incumbent United States Senators have rarely faced competitive primary challenges, and the only incumbent Senator to lose a primary was Clifford Case, a four-term Republican who lost 50.7%-49.3% to conservative Jeffrey Bell, a former speechwriter for Ronald Reagan’s 1976 presidential campaign. Case had faced primary challenges from the right before: Robert Morris, who had been Chief Counsel for Senate Internal Security Subcommittee headed by Joseph McCarthy, won 33% in 1960; and James Walter Ralph, a Bergen County physician, received 30% in 1972.
In 1970, incumbent Harrison Williams faced a Democratic primary challenge from Frank Guarini, then a State Senator from Hudson County. Williams won 66%-34%; eight years later, Guarini was elected to Congress.
One of the fiercest primaries in state history was in 1924, when Republican National Committeeman Hamilton Kean challenged Walter Edge, a former Governor who was completing his first term in the Senate. Edge won, 57%-43%, and Kean went on to win an open seat four years later.
Contributors
Wally Edge
John Adler has raised nearly $2 million so far in his bid to win election to the U.S. House of Representatives. His GOP rival, Medford Mayor ... >
Bob Torricelli
The Record announced yesterday that it was closing its Hackensack offices and "reinventing"itself. It was actually announcing its own ... >
Michael Patrick Carroll
NJ STARS, while failing in its intended purpose, nonetheless demonstrates the need for fundamental reform in NJ's high schools. >
Debbie Holtz
Twenty months ago The Daily Record's Bob Ingle gave the SCI an "A+" for its report titled "Taxpayers Beware" which ... >
Steve Lonegan
The 2009 New Jersey State Budget is not the stunning tribute to sound fiscal policy The Trenton insiders would have you believe, but just a ... >
Dr. Joseph Marbach
The budget proposed by Gov. Jon Corzine has produced myriad negative reactions, featuring various interests seeking to limit the impact of the cuts ... >
Rob Tornoe
Telecom immunity. Public financing. Faith-based initiatives. NAFTA. Just words? >
Michael P. Riccards
Recently, I walked into a large movie theatre with my wife Barbara to see "Sex and the City," the long, long rendition of themes that ... >
Carla Katz
As the Presidential election draws closer and closer, we tend to focus our attention on the daily horse race between the candidates and lose sight of ... >
Top Tags
Most Active Stories
- Katz ousted from union leadership post
- Can Jackson leave DEP before global warming report is finished?
- O'Toole welcomes new chief of staff Remy
- Round 2: Doblin takes on Torricelli
- "Entirely too comfortable with organized crime"
- DuHaime assumes top post in McCain campaign
- Kempner joins Team Obama
- Maltzman goes to work for Lautenberg
- Katz: national union “tramples democratic rights”
- Happy Fourth of July from PolitickerNJ.com
- Dr. Bones goes to Washington
- PoliticsNJ.com Power List 2007
- Eleven arrested in bribery scandal
- Lyndhurst GOP, nearly all of them, switching parties
- Lobbyist arrested
- Governor Paralysis
- Who is the best State Party Chairman in New Jersey
- KYRILLOS, BECK, KEAN & HANDLIN VOW WORK TO KEEP SEASTREAK FERRY UP AND RUNNING
- Torricelli on COAH
- Two N.J. super delegates go to Obama; Norcross backs Obama; key Clinton supporters endorse Obama
Quote of the Day
July 8, 2008
"The ordinance wasn't in effect. When it is in effect, I will abide by whatever we put forth." – Delran mayor Kenneth Paris, the sponsor of a local law that would limit township vendors to a $300 campaign contribution, after he awarded a lucrative engineering contract to a firm that donated $5,000.
-Philadelphia Inquirer, 07/08/08
Recent Press Releases
- Jul 9 2008
In the News
Read the expanded Wake Up Call, our summary of today’s news media coverage.
Today’s Must Reads:
Trump wonders why Corzine left the Senate ― CHARLES STILE
Bob Torricelli is Mad at the Big, 'Mean' Bergen Record― THE MEDIA MOB
Sweeney-Buono alliance shakes up N.J. Senate― JONATHAN TAMARI
Stile: Pay to play helped to quell party insurgents ― CHARLES STILE
Newark’s Mayor Cory Booker at Midpoint ― DICK BENFIELD
MUCHAS MARGARITAS― ANDY UNANUE
NJ Economic Growth chief leaves office― Gary Rose
Candidates spend plenty of their money― Philadelphia Inquirer
News anchor sizing up run for governor― Star-Ledger
Political parties get right down to business― Daily Record
PolitickerNJ.com Jobs
Syndicate
And
In 2008 Part time Congressman ROb Andrews embarked on an ill-guided and ill-fated run against the popular Frank Lautenberg. Lautenberg easily won the contest. Even though it was Rob's intention to build a state-wide network for a 2009 run for Governor, Rob's defeat and shady return to the House of Representatives (by way of his wife's place-holder candidacy) caused his political career to unravel.
Its Nowhere Near Over
If the primary was held today, I think Andrews would probably lose 50-45-5.
But, I think Frank Lautenberg could stumble in the next few weeks, especially when his residency on Park Avenue is further exposed.
It will be close for sure. Despite having the county lines in Bergen, Essex, and Hudson, those machines aren't going to be working at full capacity.
Andrews's support with Lesniak, Adubato, etc, may be enough to cut into FL's north jersey margin.
....but,
...but let me also agree with SJBlue that Andrews is also setting up a further run.
If FL doesn't finish out his term (a pretty likely scenario), Corzine (if re-elected in '09) would appoint Andrews for sure. Notice that Corzine hasn't bad-mouthed Andrews at all, while the Congressional delegation has.
Of course, its not clear who Chris Christie or Bill Baroni, as Governor, will appoint when FL resigns early.
it depends
The grassroots support is clearly with Andrews at this point, and turnout should favor the superior candidate in that regard. Though it is rare that challengers beat incumbents, the logic usually returns to whether the incumbent is fit for office and still delivering for the state; if that is the case -- and N.J. voters are smart -- then Andrews has a good chance at staking out a victory with a strong showing in South Jersey, a respectable showing in Middlesex, where he has almost every elected official's support, good showings in the Republican counties, where Frank has been AWOL for years, and a blunting of Lautenberg's numbers in Bergen and perhaps Hudson, though Andrews has elected officials' support in the latter, unlike Lautenberg who doesn't have a single assemblyman or senator south of Trenton supporting him.
I want Lautenberg to live to be 100
But aren't we ignoring the fact that though he is a robust 86, he's still 86! Do Dems really want that to be their legacy of transition planning? Supporting Lautenberg, no matter all the good intentions, is kinda nutty. AND I'm the biggest nut because I'll probably vote for the guy. He's been an ok Senator and I don't really know the other guy.
Grassroots support?
What grassroots support does Andrews have? He has been endorsed by a slew of legislators begging for leadership positions in the State House from George Norcross and a couple of crooked mayors like John MacCormac and Dan Reiman from Middlesex county. All the county elected officers and Congressmen are with Lautenberg. No one in this race is going with Rob Andrews because of his positions. They are going with him because of their own personal interest.
martin
Why do you think that SJ is supporting Andrews? Don't you realize that Norcross has been funding all of their campaigns? This is a no-brainer.