The race to watch next week is the contest for Bergen County Republican Chairman, where incumbent Rob Ortiz, who took over after embattled party leader Guy Talarico resigned last June, faces a challenge from former Freeholder candidate Robert Yudin and former Bergen County Utilities Authority Chairman Ben Focarino, an old hand in the BCRO who ran against Ortiz last year. Ortiz has faced criticism for, among other things, promoting the embattled Andy Unanue for the Republican U.S. Senate nomination earlier this year.
A truly wonderful article written by The Record’s Charles Stile detailing a fierce and noteworthy intra-party GOP battle in Bergen County in the 1960’s between Walter Jones and Pearce Deamer is worth the read. Click here to read: Battling for Bergen: An early-’60s attempt to seize GOP control was mano a mano.
South Jersey Democrats will back Rob Andrews' return to the U.S. House of Representatives, but some members of the party leadership aren't ... >
There's something missing from the Republican Convention. There is a need for a camera behind the curtain where speakers greet ... >
Barack Obama offers a hard-left vision for America. He would take NJ's disastrous economic policies national, and the resulting economic ... >
Selecting the next NJN anchor will certainly be a different process than what happens at the major networks, local affiliates and other public ... >
Tibet – the broad, high plateau between India and China – is bigger than Western Europe and the source of the great rivers of Asia: the Indus, ... >
For the past few weeks, I've watched with fascination as politician after politician have appeared on a beach or a boardwalk and declared their ... >
To view a larger version of this cartoon, click here. >
Speaker Nancy Pelosi, on Meet the Press, made a statement that incurred the wrath of members of the Catholic bishops club. She dared to say that ... >
And now we go back in time, to Mr. Dembo's eighth grade science class and JHS 278, and a sixteen millimeter film about the seasonal migration of ... >
Rob Ortiz
To be fair, Rob Ortiz hasn't been county chair for very long and I think that he deserves a legitimate opportunity at running the party.
As far as the whole Unanue situation is concerned, I think Ortiz realized that neither Pennacchio nor Sabrin were viable statewide candidates and that he did his best to support a candidate that he felt would have a broad appeal in the general election.
We should not be rushing Rob Ortiz out the door. Meanwhile, the state GOP needs to start looking into Hudson County and what can be done about Jose Arango who has already been long confirmed as an incompetent county GOP chairman who donates party funds to Democrats.
"Blah Blah Blah - establishment rhetoric - Blah Blah Blah" - NJMurrayPaultard
Ortiz
I think Ortiz will win. The rank-and-file respect what he's re-built. The Unanue thing was a bungle, but didn't cause any permanent damage to the party.
Time for another change
I think Rob was the great hope that busted. The total abandonment of successful campaigning for several offices last year, refusal to respect a convention vote, and other things make it time for an experienced but forward thinking guy like a Bob Yudin to come in and start cleaning up.
Orti'z biggest mistake? Too close to Wilson!
Where's Andy?
Did he come back from Colorado yet, and if so did he even vote, since he has a poor primary voting record...
Oh yea, he is a NEW YORK RESIDENT!!
Way to go Rob!
http://www.gopusanj.com
RINO mike illions of course
RINO mike illions of course knows who to support. ::cough:: kate whitman.
The Alternative
If Rob Ortiz thought Jersey Joe was no longer viable because of the manifesto, then the honorable thing to do was to call a BCRO meeting and try to rescind the endorsement up front, not work behind the back to undermind a standing endorsement by the committee.
I am guessing Ortiz loses. Bob Yudin is not an arch conservative, but at least he will listen to all sides of the party.
One other thought: even if Ortiz wins, how long until he jumps ship when he sees an opportunity that he views as better. You know he was angling for a job from Rudy. At least with Yudin, the committee can be pretty certain that he'll stick around.
i suppose
it's time for haters on parade again.
My guess is Ortiz wins easily and, he deserves to, no matter how you break it down. First of all, in less than a year, there is real progress at BCRO whether you measure it in money raised, bills paid, candidates elected or new enthusiasm. For that alone Ortiz has earned a term of his own.
Second, even if you are a hater, there is no viable alternative. Yudin can't raise money or win elections. He’s a non-starter. In his whole campaign, he has done nothing but criticize and attack Ortiz. Shouldn't he tell someone what he plans to do or how he plans to do it? Repeating “Ortiz Bad” 5 different ways is simply not going to cut it.
Don't be misled by the whole Unanue thing either. Pennacchio won the convention and the preferred ballot position that goes with it was always honored. Ortiz never even considered removing him from the line. That being said, when he and numerous other party leaders saw Estabrook's withdrawal and news of the manifesto, they thought that the voters might like another choice. That’s not disrespect, that’s leadership. That leadership and that wisdom, I'd say, was borne out by Zimmer's convincing win yesterday. Unanue may have been a flawed candidate but the concept of another choice was not.
Also, before you annoint Bob Y as the hero/protector of the county committee, remember back to last year when Talarico refused to hold a convention for D40 and dictated that his candidates got the line over sitting legislators. Bob had a chance to speak up and defend the county committee's right to choose, but he did not. He stayed quiet and went along with the Talarico program to protect his spot on the line as a freeholder candidate. He cannot claim to be county committe's champion now, when he threw them squarely under the bus last year to protect his own ballot position. Bob Y’s links to the disastrous Talarico regime is reason enough why he can’t be seriously considered for Chairman.
To his credit, Ortiz has spoken only about was has been accomplished and what can be accomplished in the future. He hasn’t said a negative thing about his 2 rivals. All the bashers here have is conjecture and supposition about motives and commitment. It is absurd. Look at the facts. BCRO is in far better shape than it was 10 months ago. On the whole, Rob Ortiz has done a good job. He is the right choice to continue the progress.
Time for UNITY is now
If the Dems can come together after their bitter in fighting why cant we.? Just imagine the combined money and energy, youth and experience of a fusion ticket Ortiz, Ben F , Bob Y, Rob Schroeder, Bill Thomson etc etc. The Dems have voted for Corruption Inc to continue in Bergen County. Its time for a taxpayers bill of rights in Bergen. It will be interesting to see who will be first to put their ego aside after this race and get on board.
UNITY 101
Don't start/support divisive intra-party challenge to sitting Chair when things are plainly getting better
Ortiz is a joke.
He hates conservatives, is a single issue abortion zealot and his influence can be seen by Dick Zimmer's second worst showing in the state. At least Yudin wants to win. All Ortiz is looking for is a payday.
wow
Wow, Rick-if that's the best spin you've got then it's no surprise you're usually unemployed.
If you knew any better then you would know that Bob Yudin is a staunch pro choice, anti gun candidate.
How much is he paying you to blog on this site, Rick?
golly rick
i'm guessing someone whizzed on your cornflakes this am. Wanting to win is great but for all those earnest hopes and desires, Bob Y has never gotten it done. Criminy, because of his prior 50,000 and 40,000 vote losses, he can actually claim that last year's 12,000 vote loss was a drastic improvement.
I'm not saying he's a bad guy. He's stepped up in the past and that is something. Bottom line though is he is not the guy for this job and everybody knows it. The only people I see supporting him are people looking to advance their own interests and agendas, not the interests of the party.
oh yeah, your rant is just unsupportable paranoid drivel.
Reality Check - Part 2.
Rob Ortiz -
1. Respected the BCRO convention vote. Senator Pennacchio still had the BCRO line.
2. Got the BCRO out of debt.
3. Has raised roughly $200,000 for Republican candidates in Bergen County.
4. Has reached out to Young Republicans and motivated people to get more involved by volunteering, contributing and attending events.
Reality Check 2008 Part 2 -
This leadership challenge is foolish, and a wasted opportunity. True leaders do not squander opportunities. A leadership shake-up now when the Bergen Democrats are in the midst of their own internal battle, would be a needless distraction from the issues and getting our candidates elected. We are focussed on this Chairman's election, rather than the issues important to taxpayers. That in itself is inexcusable and the challengers and their supporters should be held accountable. If a candidate needs Bergen to win statewide, then we need a leader with vision. We need a leader with a history of winning elections and uniting people.
Rob Ortiz is that leader.
Typical
Throughlymoderatemillie, of course, brands anyone who disagrees with her as a hater. That's right out of the John Lindsey handbook.
The fact is that Rob Ortiz hasn't just taken the highroad. He took potshots at his critics in his three-page letter. And the suggestion that he respected the BCRO decision because Jersey Joe remained on the county line is absurd. Ortiz could not legally remove Jersey Joe from the line, but he did everything he could to undermine his candidacy. As for Bob Yudin not being able to fundraise or "get it done," I can tell you that I got more campaign mailings financed by Yudin last year than by the BCRO. That says a lot. And Ortiz did absolutely nothing to assist the candidates in the 39th, let alone the 37th.
I freely accept that Bob Yudin is not a staunch conservative. But at least he will listen to all sides of the party. Ortiz will never unify the party because he has made it perfectly clear that he only cares about one wing of the party.
Also, Yudin will spend more time at being chair. Ortiz has a fulltime job as a lobbyist-attorney and young kids. You can bet that even if reelected, he will jump ship at the first good opportunity. In the meantime, we should try to beat the Democrats by offering a difference, instead of imitating their party's imperial bossism in Bergen.
correction & more blunders
Yudin did ask for the convention to be opened up 2 years ago. Donovan and her orange hats (oh wait she was part of a costly primary got open arms to run from Ortiz this year). Yudin and Gerry said let there be a vote but Guy and his 2 bodyguards (Miller and Flynn) decided not to have any of it. Yudin has gotten the support of CC each of the last 4 years (lost to Cassano by 6 votes in his first run) and i think he will be 100% committed to the BCRO & County Committe. Another Ortiz blunder: Mayor Hipp wins huge on an anti ENCAP stance. Ortiz encourages him to meet with Trump and make nice nice. So the one issue we win on he wants to take away from us.
Actually ....
A hater is someone who criticizes and drops bombs for the sole purpose of damaging someone else.
You wanna disagree with me go ahead. I respect that. That doesn't make you a hater. Just be fair and be accurate. The gop.observer and vincognito posts are neither fair nor accurate.
As for the observer, I saw no potshots in the Ortiz letter. I think you are a tad sensitive. On the other hand, has Bob Y said anything, anything other than Rob Ortiz is the devil? He hasn't told us why he would be a good chairman, can you? Is all the money he has raised...no can't be that. Is it all the elections he has won...strike 2. Wait, maybe it's his relationships throughout the state and the country with party leadership, donors and others who can get things done...no, those are Ortiz's relationships.
You are also wrong about the line. As chair Ortiz did have the legal authority to remove Pennacchio from the line. He couldn't have been plainer that he never considered that as an option. Funny, though, I noticed that you didn't respond to the part about Bob choosing to protect himself last year rather than standing up when Guy screwed the county committee and sitting legislators. Do you have an answer for that?
You got more mail from Yudin, that's great. How'd that work out for you? Maybe it cut the margin of defeat from 40,000 to 12,000. Not exactly what we should be writing home about. Ortiz raised more money in less than a year than Talarico raised in over 2 years.
What wing of the party is it that Ortiz favors? What is that based on? You're just making this up aren't you?
Your last paragraph is barely worth dignifying with a reponse. Are we to understand that you have some keen insight into Rob's priorities, hopes and aspirations? You're just making that up too aren't you.
As for vin, that post is less silly but still flawed. Yes, Bob Y did call for an open convention 2 years ago and that was the right call. I never said he was a bad guy, I just think he is incredibly misguided. As right as he may have been in '06, we was that wrong in "07. He still has to answer for his choice last year when he stood with Guy while he totally neutered the county committee. That was a far more egregious insult to the sovereignty of the county committee than the Pennacchio non-situation this year. Bob chose to look out for himself. Bob's entire position on that issue is therefore totally hypocritical.
He also still has to answer for calling out Assemblywoman Vandervalk after the '06 primary when he screamed "you're next Charlotte...we're coming after you next" Or is that how he is going to listen to all sides of the party?
As for ENCAP, regardless of what you say, shouldn't we be most influenced by the fact that Mayor Hipp is enthusiastically supporting Ortiz's re-election.
If you guys want to debate I'm all for it. Just read this post first. Note that it deals with facts, that there is no speculation or guesswork, and no insults. See if you can do the same.
I wonder what Pennacchio thinks about Ortiz now.
My bet is that Jersey Joe does not think that Ortiz is a leader. Neither does Dr. Sabrin. That alone disqualifies him from the leadership position in BCRO.
stop this bad press now
http://www.northjersey.com/news/bergenpolitics/Jersey_Joe_nearly_scored_... Its time for everyone on all sides to stop the fighting and donate to the local and county candidates now. If you dont donate you really cannot complain. Did any of you donate last year ? Did any of you walk with or donate $$$ to Judith Fisher last year ? or the county team ? We cannot afford any more bad press. Who is going to step up and unite after Tuesday ?
Morris
One of Bergen's biggest problems is not having a good working relationship with heavy R and money rich Morris COunty. Ceritnally Yudin and his support of Jersey Joe can help with that. After what Ortiz did - we won't see anything from Morris.
is that all you have vin
you are truly grasping for straws now
that is probably the most nonsensical statement i have ever seen on this site and there have been some doozies
if i were a betting man, i'd wager that the Pennacchio camp would agree that Ortiz is the better choice for chair
there is no problem with Morris County and even if there were, it wouldn't be an issue
As a Yudin supporter, i'm guessing you really don't want to talk about which candidate has better party connections THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE STATE
Check this out
http://www.chairmanrobortiz.com
http://www.bobyudin.vom
Bob Yudin has only two endorsements? Rob Ortiz has a huge list of endorsements.
Ortiz by a landslide.