A decade ago, there were ten Republicans who dominated politics in their counties: Bill Gormley in Atlantic, Pat Schuber in Bergen, Glenn Paulsen in Burlington, James Treffinger in Essex, Robert Prunetti in Mercer, Harry Larrison in Monmouth, George Gilmore in Ocean, Peter Murphy in Passaic, Dale Florio in Somerset, and Donald DiFrancesco in Union. Today, Democrats have completely overtaken five of those counties, and the Republicans are now playing defense in the other five.
In 1997, Bergen Republicans controlled the County Executive post (Schuber won re-election in ’94), had a 7-0 majority of the Freeholder Board, and had GOP State Senators in districts 36, 38, 39 and 40. Democrats won the County Executive office when Schuber retired in 2002, and now hold all seven Freeholder seats; County Clerk Kathleen Donovan is the lone Republican elected countywide. And if Gerald Cardinale loses his bid for re-election, there would be no Republican State Senators from Bergen County for the first time since 1967.
Prunetti, who retired in 2003, and Treffinger, who was indicted in 2002, were replaced by Democratic County Executives. In county contests, the GOP is no longer competitive. (The two Republican Freeholders in Essex and the Republican County Clerk in Mercer are gone.) In Passaic, Murphy’s Republican domination of the Board of Freeholders went from 7-0 to 0-7; Passaic no longer has a Republican State Senator and County Clerk, powerful GOP Sheriff Edwin Englehardt is gone – replaced by powerful Democratic Sheriff Gerald Speziale.
In Atlantic, Gormley, the de facto GOP boss for twenty years, has retired. So has DiFrancesco, who as Senate President in the 1990’s helped finance Republicans in Union County.
Republicans are defending their control of county government in Atlantic and Monmouth this year, and trying to stop Democratic gains in Burlington (where Paulsen has now returned, albeit through his next door neighbor) and Somerset. And in Ocean County, where the GOP has no real problems at the county level, Gilmore is trying hard to pick up key mayoral posts in Toms River and Brick.
Chris Christie’s refusal to have his picture taken with Rick Merkt at a Republican event in Summit was probably just the former federal ... >
It's hard to not be concerned these days. We've all witnessed frustration with our institutions before but I never remember anything of this ... >
Instead of borrowing trillions to waste on make-work governmental projects, stimulate the economy with tax cuts. >
Score one for the Governor’s public relations team. For the last few weeks, they have been working overtime to fuel speculation Corzine was being ... >
With the entrance of Chris Christie into the Republican gubernatorial primary, the GOP has greatly enhanced its chances of capturing the ... >
Hard to believe we have arrived at the last year of the first decade of the 21st century. Boy, seems like it was just yesterday that Bush was handed ... >
It's actually come to this: A panel convened by the legislature of the State of New Jersey has concluded that discrimination is not good. Maybe ... >
As it tends to, history seems to be repeating itself as 240 laid-off workers at Republic Windows and Doors in Chicago revive a decades old tactic -- ... >
Many columnists write a "year in review" or a "predictions" piece for the New Year, however I decided to refrain from going down ... >
Yesterday President-elect Barack Obama outlined his American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan in a speech at George Mason University. Obama said we ... >
blame game
Seems to me that the loss of control of the Statehouse (2001) and then legislaure begat fundraising problems for the GOP on a statewide level, which in turn begat losses on the county level, as the funding from the State party and leadership committees wasn't there anymore.
So blame the statewide GOP for not winning a statewide race, and blame John Bennett for losing the legislature too, while we're at it.
Cause & Effect
It seems obvious that there was a cause & effect here. The GOP needs a center-right coalition to win in the long-term, and that coalition is largely dead because most of the above leaders could care less about taking any conservative positions on just about anything. They just sought to get elected by popularity or incumbency and left the party weaker rather than stronger at the end of their tenure. Given the choice of voting for Democrats and imitation Democrats, voters will usually choose the real thing.
Will the NJ GOP always be more moderate than the sunbelt GOP? Yes. But it still needs to be right-of-center to offer voters an alternative. Until the Whitman wing of the party understands that, the party is doomed to minority status.
You got it right
"Given the choice between Democrats and imitiation democrats, voters will usually choose the real thing."
The GOP (my party) needs a genuine platform. "Lower taxes" and "ethics reform" are simply not ideas. Voters can sniff out an empty phrase pretty quickly. They can see a candidate going through the motions. And as for the "Choice for Change" platform, does anyone believe the GOP really wants initiative and referendum?
When the GOP gets spanked again this year, maybe we will finally become more than just an echo of whatever the Democrats say.
Hummmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!
Oh!
Let's re-elect Loser Tom Wilson again he's done such a great and continuous job of LOSING.
I guess all those berg's are still around in the CRACKS not to be seen anymore.
"I'm With Fred"
Hint for republicans
It is my belief that many Americans are centrists or progressive. Liberal? not even the democratic party is liberal anymore. The one thing that kills the republican ticket is not being on par with the times- meaning the main stream population and the young voters. It's my belief that republicans have lost their way -the true republican way, by catering to the bible belt and their funding. The holier than thou, bible pushing form of conservatism is not very popular, especially in NJ. That is not conservatism, it's religious fanatism. True conservatism id government and is what the republicans have forgotten in favor of big bible sponsorships. I respected Ronald Reagan he was a true republican and a decent man (I met him). Even though I did not agree with many of his policies, I admire him to this day. He was a religious man, but did not shove it down people's throats. You are all not progressive enough, and need to get back to true government-not just moral agendas.
The "republic" is government, not a church, or the voice of morals for freedom of choice. If you guys ever start to understand that, then you will have a chance. Believe it or not, i am not writing this as an anti-republican message but with rather nostalgic feelings of rememberance of doing battle with real honest republicans. All the luck to you.
Say wha?
Liberal? The whole party is a bunch of liberals, only they call themselves "progressives" today -- pretty much for the same reason that abortionists call themselves "women's health care providers."
Right on Nemo
This is excellent insight. As a conservative Catholic, but one who does not let faith dictate politics, I have been frustrated on one hand by the RINO's infinite stupidity in running elitist candidates with no popular appeal, and on the other hand the Religious Wrong imposing its absurdity and the two groups squabbling off, all while acting like its still far in the past. As we see, neither group is truly reliable for the Republican Party, just ask Bret Schundler about the former in 2001 or Rudy Giuliani about the latter today.
Young people have turned away from the GOP, but not because the Democrats are so great, but because we emphasize the wrong issues. Look at a Republican like Ron Paul who is running as a traditional true conservative, he is winning mass support among people of all ages. The other Republicans running seem more and more unable to define themselves in a future context.
And Wilson has really brought this party to its knees. The NJGOP need not be a subsidiary of Turnkey Productions. Isn't it the party chairs job to recruit candidates? Why wasn't Wilson meeting throughout 2006 with local Republicans in every possible pickup district to find good people who fit the area to run. Instead we end up with joke candidates like Mike Guarino who can't win their own precinct and make their Democratic rivals look good by comparison.
There are plenty of good Republicans in this not-so-blue state, but our party leaders keep giving us the blues.
Mass
"Look at a Republican like Ron Paul who is running as a traditional true conservative, he is winning mass support among people of all ages."
Huh?